Parenting Blind
Well done you, parenting like a pro! That sounds like a real achievement in the parenting roller coaster of life. I sometimes like to imagine what we would all be like if we were always treated with love, patience and understanding.
My latest parenting challenge has come from a corner of the parenting world I should be more than familiar with - reading and books! I am a professional teacher of English and frequently recommend books for our school library, so the world of fiction for 12 to 16 year olds really should be a walk in the park for me.
Not so, not so.
A while back, on a spending spree in Waterstones, B chose a book called 'Wildlands' by Brogen Murphy. He was delighted by the idea of it. The blurb on the back read: "Twenty-five years into the future, no humans are allowed in the Wildlands - a vast rewilded area in Britain where wolves, lynx and bison roam free. The only exception is a high speed rail line that runs through the project. Thirteen year old Astrid and her little sister, Indie, are on board when their train slows to a brief, unexpected stop...and they find themselves accidentally left behind. STranded, they have only a rucksack, a phone without signal - and each other. As every wrong turn takes them deeper into the Wildlands, do they have the resourcefulness and determination to survive?'
The blurb is important.
B was excited and set off reading the book independently. However, as term got into full flow and he was asked to take up another book for school, Wildlands got left aside. I was sad about that and asked him about it and he spoke about not having a choice except to read the book he had been given in school. I thought this strange and asked the school, but indeed it was true. I protested and the rule was changed and we decided to take up Wildlands as a family, with B as our narrator.
The book was okay. The girls did get out of the train and were stranded, but there were not any wild animals much. Astrid reflected that she had not been speaking to Mum or Ma. Two mums. We easily talked about different types of family and everyone to be respected and carried on. Still no wild animals much and the girls didn't seem to like nature.
Astrid revealed, in her thoughts, more and more about the breakdown of her relationship with her Ma. A flashback revealed that she had found a document, a contract. She had thought she was adopted. Whilst we were frustrated at the lack of story about the wild animals, this was once again a quick evening conversation about there being many different types of family. None of these areas were new to us - we'd covered same sex relationships and adoption when we read the very exciting Skandar series.
I finally gave up on the book after listening to B read this section aloud:
{Flashback]
She read the contract again, making herself go slowly and not just skimming the main words.
CHILD couldn't mean her? Her parents had her through cross-egg insemination. It was how two women could make a baby and both be the genetic parent. Astrid remembered her parents explaining all about it when Ma was pregnant with Indie.
Astrid was made the same way. Of course she was....It has always been that way, she knew. Her oldest cousin was nearly ten years older than Astrid, and he had two mums as well. His parents hadn't been able to make a baby with just two of them, because the technology didn't exist back then. They'd used....and there it was, stored in the back of her memory, that word....a donor.
Astrid looked back down at the paper in her hand. It was shaking now, making it hard to read the words. Mark was the DONOR. Ma was the RECIPIENT.
Recipient of ...her?
But if Mark was the DONOR and Ma was the RECIPIENT, and she, Astrid, was the CHILD....
What did that make Mum?
I am not averse to big, hard topics in books. I read Kasuro Ishiguro's 'Never Let Me Go' to Year 10 every year.
I am averse to having big, hard topics snuck into books marketed at 8 -12 year olds without any indication of the content on the blurb or in the first chapters. I checked the marketing for Wildlands after this section and found that it was a book recommended to schools for children in Years 4 - 6. I have two children in that age bracket and I can tell you that neither of them understood what was being discussed, had any understanding of the moral or ethical implications of the topic, and would much rather the book kept to the central theme of surviving amongst wild animals!
As a teacher of both literature and ethics and philosophy, I found this trojan horse attitude to very complex and challenging ethical areas irresponsible. I was not ready to explain the medical information necessary to explore such an area; my children, whilst country children well versed in some of the mechanics of reproduction are not interested in talking about sex or relationships. And, why should they be? So, what was the point of this entire sub-plot? Before putting the book away completely, I read further alone. It turns out that the sub-plot becomes the plot. Mark is dead, so Indie, the little sister, was in fact made using cross-egg insemination. Now, not only was the relationship with Mum in question, but so was the relationship with the sister. Wild animals did not make an appearance.
My conclusion? This was a political agenda being snuck into a children's book. It treated the making of the human person as a commodity to be afforded and technologies to be developed. There was no ethical issue about the experimentation required to develop such technologies and any idea of human sanctity was long gone. This was propaganda that made ethical debate impossible because it was marketed at an audience too young to question or understand what was at stake. And, if B had read the whole thing independently, I am not sure he would have even had the vocabulary or understanding to question what he was reading. The whole book would have been 'stored in the back' of his 'memory', as the protagonist observes happens to young people.
The next day, I did something I had never done before.
At story time, I picked up 'The Magician's Nephew' by CS Lewis. B asked once where Wildlands had gone. I said, I was finding it rather boring. 'Me too', he said, 'No animals'.And do you know what? CS Lewis has started an ethical debate in our house since - Is it right to try and invade and take over other worlds? We talked about the use of force and violence when Diggory gripped Polly's arm to force her to do something she didn't want to. We talked about why the Magician's Nephew is a bad character and why the Cabby and his wife are such good characters. We have wondered about the identity of Aslan and if the witch from Charn will become the White Witch of the Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe.
B is still reading, but he seems to have a lot more questions now. Perhaps that is because the book he is reading really is 'a story for children' and it is doing what good literature should do - it is allowing him to ask those questions?'

Comments
Post a Comment